🧾 Understanding Cyber Insurance:
What It Covers, What It Doesn’t, and Whether It’s Worth Your Money
Cyber insurance is being marketed as the ultimate digital safety net. And with ransomware headlines, phishing attacks, and data breach lawsuits making the rounds, it’s no wonder that more businesses—from solo consultants to multinational firms—are asking:
“Should we get cyber insurance?”
The answer? It depends on what you're expecting it to do.
This post unpacks what cyber insurance actually covers, what it doesn’t, how much protection it really offers, and how to decide if it's worth the premium for your situation.
🕳️ First, a Hard Truth: Insurance ≠ Immunity
Cyber insurance is not a forcefield. It won’t stop ransomware from encrypting your files or phishing emails from hitting your inbox. It doesn’t block malware or alert you to unusual logins.
Cyber insurance is a financial backstop—not a shield.
So before you sign up, you need to understand what you're buying.
🔍 What Does Cyber Insurance Cover?
Most policies are split into first-party (your business) and third-party (your clients or partners) coverage. Here's what you might expect:
🧾 First-Party Coverage:
Incident response & forensic investigations
Data restoration (after encryption or corruption)
Business interruption losses
Ransom payments (if allowed/legal)
Public relations crisis support
📤 Third-Party Liability:
Lawsuits from clients or partners
Regulatory fines (GDPR, HIPAA, etc.—depends on policy)
Privacy violations and data exposure claims
💡 Some policies now even include 24/7 breach coaches or access to pre-negotiated forensic firms.
❌ What Cyber Insurance Usually Doesn’t Cover
Before you feel too reassured, here’s the fine print that gets missed in the sales pitch:
Acts of war or nation-state attacks (e.g., NotPetya, which devastated global supply chains but was declared “an act of war” by some insurers)
Unpatched software or known vulnerabilities
Negligence or lack of basic security controls
Losses from insider threats (unless explicitly included)
Reputation damage (unless bundled in a crisis add-on)
🧠 Translation: If your passwords are “123456” or you skipped basic security training, good luck getting that claim paid.
📈 Real-World Case: Merck vs. Its Insurer
Pharma giant Merck suffered $1.4B in damage from the NotPetya malware. Their cyber insurance claim was denied on the basis that the attack was a “hostile or warlike act” tied to geopolitical conflict. Merck sued—and eventually won.
But the fight took years. And many smaller businesses wouldn’t have the legal stamina to go the distance.
🧠 Is It Worth It? Ask These 5 Questions First
Do you hold sensitive data?
(Customer info, health data, payment details?)Can you afford days of downtime or lost sales?
Would a client sue you over a breach?
Do you work in a regulated industry?
Do you already have good cyber hygiene in place?
(Insurance won’t protect you from poor security.)
If you answered “yes” to 2 or more, you need to at least consider cyber insurance seriously.
💸 How Much Does It Cost?
Premiums vary wildly depending on:
Your industry
Revenue and size
Past incidents or claims
Security controls you have in place
✅ More security = lower premiums.
Insurers now demand proof of MFA, EDR, patching policies, and backup plans before underwriting.
“Cyber insurance is now a cybersecurity audit in disguise.”
📃 What to Look for in a Policy
Clear definitions of covered vs excluded events
Incident response partnerships included
Minimum security requirements (read carefully)
Coverage for ransomware and legal support
Retroactive breach coverage if data was stolen before detection
🧠 So… Is Cyber Insurance Worth It?
Yes—if you treat it as the last layer of your defence, not the first.
It’s for when your best efforts still weren’t enough.
Cyber insurance won’t protect you—but it can protect your business continuity, your finances, and your future after an incident.
But only if you read the fine print, meet the conditions, and don’t assume it’s a substitute for security.
🧭 Final Thoughts
Cyber insurance isn’t a luxury for big corporations anymore.
It’s becoming a cost of doing business in a world where a single email click can cost six figures.
But remember: It only pays out after the damage is done.
Investing in prevention—MFA, training, backups, response plans—is still cheaper, faster, and safer than relying on the mercy of an insurance adjuster.
🔐 Want to know if your business is cyber-insurable?
Subscribe to The Cyber Compass for weekly breakdowns, checklists, and insights designed to help you secure your systems, clients, and sanity.